An herbal infusion steeps herbs in water off the heat. A decoction keeps the herbs in the pot at a gentle simmer. I don’t choose between them based on how “strong” I want a cup to be. I start with the plant part, how finely it’s cut, and what I want to bring out in the finished preparation.

Infusion vs. decoction at a glance

Covered hot infusion Gentle decoction
Pour hot water over the herb. Cover and steep off the heat. Keep the herb in water at a gentle simmer on the stove.
A good starting point for tender leaves and flowers. A good starting point for dense, woody roots and bark.
Try it with nettle leaf or lemon balm. Try it with cut-and-sifted, unroasted dandelion root.

A covered infusion for nettle and lemon balm

White teapot next to loose nettle leaves and a spoon
Loose nettle leaf beside the teapot, ready for a covered infusion.

Put your dried herbs in a heat-safe teapot or mug, pour freshly boiled water over them, cover, and steep before straining. A covered infusion is a good starting point for many leafy or aromatic herbs. The lid matters most when you want to keep the aroma in the cup instead of letting it drift out with the steam.

Dried nettle leaf has a green, earthy taste. If you like that flavor but want a brighter finish, try steeping it with a little lemon balm leaf. Smell the herbs dry, then smell the cup when you lift the lid. It’s a simple way to notice what each plant contributes.

A gentle decoction for dandelion root

Hands using a mortar and pestle beside pieces of dried dandelion root
A close look at cut dandelion root before it goes into the saucepan.

A dense, woody root is a different starting point. For unroasted dandelion root, I use 1 tablespoon of the cut-and-sifted root in 2 cups of water. Bring it to a gentle simmer, cover, and simmer for 10 to 15 minutes before straining. At the shorter end the cup is lighter; closer to 15 minutes it has more body.

This is a starting point for this particular cut of dandelion root, not a timing rule for every root. If you switch the herb, change the size of the pieces, or use a roasted version, don’t assume you’ll get the same result.

Cut roots, including dandelion root, gently simmering in a stainless steel saucepan.
Dandelion root simmering with other roots in my spiced fall decoction. The single-herb preparation above uses a shorter simmer.

When to steep a root instead of simmering it

The plant part gives me a starting point, not a rule. If I want the bright aroma of fresh ginger, I’ll try thin slices in a covered hot infusion first. When I want a more pronounced ginger bite in a root blend, I’ll simmer it instead and taste as I go.

Marshmallow root is a different kind of exception. I use a cold infusion in the refrigerator when I want its silky texture. In both cases, I choose the method by what I want in the finished cup, not just by the fact that I’m working with a root.

What if your blend has both roots and leaves?

You don’t have to choose one method for the whole blend. For herbs that make sense together, simmer the dense root first. Take the pot off the heat, add the more delicate leaf, cover to steep, then strain. This gives each plant part the preparation it needs without keeping the leafy herbs on the stove for the entire simmer.

That’s the distinction I’d keep in mind at your own workbench: choose the method for the herb and the cut in front of you. Then taste, take notes, and adjust one thing the next time you make it. If you’re stocking your apothecary for both methods, start with the organic dried herbs collection.

— Laura D’Itri